Rekey or Replace? What to Do With Your Locks After Buying a Home

October 14, 2026

You got the keys at closing, and the house finally feels like yours. The trouble is, you have no idea who else has a set.

Past owners, their relatives, cleaners, dog walkers and contractors may all have copies. Keypad codes and garage remotes can be floating around too.

Changing who can get in should be one of your first jobs in a new home, ideally before the furniture arrives. The two main options are rekeying and replacing, and each fits a different situation.

Rekeying vs. Replacing: The Quick Version

  • Rekeying changes the inside of the lock cylinder to work with a new key. Old keys stop working, and the hardware stays on the door.
  • Replacing swaps the whole lock for new hardware. It's your chance to upgrade the grade, the style or the type of lock.

Both cut off old keys. The real difference is whether the existing hardware is worth keeping.

You can also mix the two. Rekey the solid locks now, and replace the worn ones as budget and time allow.

When Rekeying Makes Sense

  • The locks turn smoothly and feel solid
  • You like the look and the finish
  • You want every exterior door on one key
  • You'd rather not pay for hardware you don't need

Some locks can even be rekeyed by the homeowner. Kwikset's SmartKey Security locks rekey with the current working key and a small tool.

That system only works on Kwikset locks. If your home came with SmartKey hardware, you'll need a working key plus the tool that ships in the original package.

When Replacement Is the Better Call

  • The lock sticks, wobbles or needs jiggling to turn
  • The finish is worn through or the hardware is damaged
  • The deadbolt has no BHMA grade, or a low one, and you want a stronger lock
  • You want a keypad or smart lock
  • Your doors have mixed brands that can't share one key without new hardware

Replacing is also the moment to check the door itself. A new deadbolt can't do much in a frame that's loose or splitting.

If you're leaning toward new locks or keyless entry, compare BHMA grades before you compare styles.

A Five-Minute Check at Every Door

Walk each exterior door, including the back, side and garage entry doors, and run through this:

  1. Turn the key. Does it slide in and turn without forcing?
  2. Throw the bolt with the door open. Does it extend fully and feel solid?
  3. Close the door and lock it. Does the bolt slide in without lifting or pushing the door?
  4. Look at the face of the lock. Note the brand and check for wear, rust or loose trim.
  5. Count your keys. How many different keys does it take to open every door?

Smooth, solid and matching? Rekey. Sticky, wobbly or a jumble of brands? Replace, or fix the door first.

Don't Forget the Other "Keys"

Keypad and smart lock codes

Delete every stored user code, not just the main one. Then set new codes for your household.

Smart home devices

The FTC advises smart home buyers to reset connected devices to factory settings, review privacy settings and set up their own accounts.

Then update each device right away. That includes smart locks, video doorbells, cameras and thermostats.

Garage door openers

Old remotes and keypad codes can still open your garage. On many openers, holding the Learn button until its light goes out erases every stored remote and keypad code.

The steps vary by brand and model, so check the opener's manual. Then reprogram only the remotes you're keeping.

Hidden spares and lockboxes

Check under mats, planters, rocks and porch lights for spare keys. Ask your agent to remove any lockbox still on the property.

Make It Part of Your Move-In Checklist

Locks are one item on a longer first-week list. While you're walking the house, test the smoke alarms and check their dates.

Bought new construction? Pair this with an 11-month builder warranty walkthrough while your builder's warranty is still in effect.

Everything else, from loose towel bars to sticky doors, can go on a one-visit honey-do list.

Hiring Help in Tennessee

Tennessee repealed its Locksmith Licensing Act in 2021, so the state no longer licenses locksmiths.

That puts the vetting on you. Ask for a written quote, check recent reviews, and make sure you know exactly what's being rekeyed or replaced.

When the work is done, test every new key in every door before the pro leaves. A key that sticks on day one won't get better.

Start Your First Week Locked Down

If the hardware is solid, rekey it. If it's worn, weak or not what you want, replace it.

Either way, reset the codes, remotes and smart devices too. A new key doesn't help much if the old garage remote still works.

Ready for new hardware? Harper's Handyman Services installs new deadbolts and keyless entry locks for new homeowners across the Nashville area. Call 615-289-8216 or get a free quote.

‍

Blog Author Image

Get a free Quote